Signature Sandwiches
St. Pete Savory
This is the sandwich you have to try. We mix a savory cashew butter with fig jelly, then add sprouts, avocado, and Frank’s Red Hot sauce. It sounds weird right up until your first bite, and then you’re hooked. vg
$10.00
Thai Fighter
The force is strong with this one. Straight from a galaxy far far away, we’ve come up with something out of this world. We take a curry peanut butter and pair it with sweet pepper jelly. We top it with crushed peanuts, fresh basil, and Sriracha. Not convinced yet? After it’s assembled, the whole thing is pressed. BOOM! vg
$10.00
Italian Goat
How is this even a pb&j sandwich? Our mad scientist sandwich artist pulled this one from across the Napoli Bay by combining walnut pesto goat cheese butter (yeah, you read that right), banana peppers, tomato jam and topping it off with a balsamic reduction and pressed like a panini!
$10.00
Cherry Bomb
Your kids are going to go crazy for this one, and secretly so are you. We spread chocolate almond butter, cherry jelly, and marshmallow fluff on your choice of one of our amazing breads. Your taste buds will explode.
$9.00
The Happy Apple
Need a smile? This is the sandwich that will leave you feeling happy. How about salted caramel peanut butter mixed with apple butter, and sliced green apples. Makes your mouth water, doesn’t it?
$9.00
Strawberry Fields
This one is just for you St. Pete. We’ve taken your favorite Mazzaro’s Fatboy Bread and smothered it with gourmet strawberry preserve and our house-made cashew butter. If that’s not good enough, we layer on some fresh organic Baby Arugula lightly tossed in Vinaigrette and top that with feta cheese and freshly sliced strawberries. It’s like running across a field towards your soulmate in slow motion, but for your mouth.
$10.00
Seasonal Sandwich
It’s Fall Y’all
Nothing says fall like a pb&j that reminds you of years past. Try pumpkin walnut butter matched with apple cider jam, then top it with marshmallow fluff, sliced apples, and rice crispy cereal. It’s like a crackling fire in your mouth, without all that burning your mouth nonsense.
$10.00
Build Your Own
Got an idea for a sandwich. Pick one nut butter and one jelly from the list.
$8.00
Bread
- white (provided by Mazzaro’s)
- gluten free (add $3)
Nut Butters
- Salted Caramel Peanut Butter
- Chocolate Almond Butter
- Savory Cashew Butter
- Almond Butter
- Regular Peanut Butter
- Cashew Butter
- Walnut Butter
Jellies
- Grape
- Cherry
- Strawberry
- Fig
- Apple Butter
- Pepper Jelly
Add-Ons
Jazz it up with something extra.
$1.00 each
- Banana
- Apple
- Marshmallow Fluff
- Honey
- Banana peppers
- Siracha
- Hot Sauce
- Crushed Peanuts
A La Carte
Round out your meal with chips and a drink.
$2.00 each
- Dirty’s Potato Chips
- Bottled Water
- Can of Coke or Sprite
PB & Jelly Deli 